How to Choose Between PSA, Beckett and CGC

Updated · 1 min read

Quick answer

Choose a grading company based on what you want from the card, the all-in quote for your submission, and what buyers have paid for comparable copies in that grader’s holder. For a card you plan to keep, the holder and service can matter more than the resale spread.

Collector in a butterfly-print cap inspecting a clear card holder next to an open binder beneath the DAIG wordmark

Compare the grade and holder your buyer would see

Start with completed sales of the same card number, language, printing and variant. Group by grading company and the exact label. A grade with a qualifier, a top-tier designation, or a different holder generation can attract a different price. Keep those details in your comparison instead of pooling every sale with the same number.

The PSA grading scale guide explains PSA’s number grades and qualifiers. For Beckett and CGC, check their published scales below and compare the labels in your actual sale examples.

What to compare across PSA, Beckett and CGC
CompanyCheck on the labelCheck before submitting
PSANumeric grade and any qualifierService eligibility, declared value and total submission cost
Beckett (BGS)Overall grade and any displayed subgradesWhich service and label options apply to your cards
CGC CardsExact grade term and label generationCurrent grading scale and return options for your location

Get an all-in quote for the same submission

Ask each company or submission partner what you would pay for the same cards. Record the service fee, shipping both ways, insurance, handling charges and any minimum order size. If you are submitting internationally, ask which costs the quote includes and who handles the return paperwork.

Use the submission checklist to compare packaging and service requirements. Then plug each quote and plausible sale outcome into the profit calculator. A lower fee can still leave you with less on resale when comparable sold prices differ.

Match the service to your reason for grading

For resale, compare what you would keep after expenses at a conservative grade. If you find too few sold copies for one grader, keep that as a gap in the evidence. For a collection, look at the holder and label in person when possible, and weigh the quote and turnaround against how you plan to store or display the card.

A phone scan can help decide which cards deserve an inspection before you pay. Our digital pre-grading workflow shows how to take and verify those photos. The company you submit to assigns the official grade after reviewing the physical card.

Frequently asked questions

Is a 10 worth the same from every card grading company?
Prices can differ by company, label and exact card. Check completed sales of the same variant and grade label before estimating what your card could sell for.
Which grading company should I choose for a card I plan to keep?
Compare holder and label preferences, submission convenience and the total cost. Ask how the service handles your card type and how the card will be returned to you.

Sources

Stop guessing.
Start grading smarter.

Digital AI Grading checks condition, centering and raw vs graded value from a scan of your card. Free to download on iPhone.